In 1809, systematic excavations commenced on the extensive Torlonia estates along the Appian Way, particularly in the area historically known as Roma Vecchia, encompassing the localities of Caffarella, Quadraro, and Anzio. Of particular importance were the excavations conducted in the vicinity of the Villa of the Quintilii, directed by the archaeologist Antonio Nibby, which continued until 1861 and yielded a substantial number of imperial-era artifacts.
Alongside these archaeological undertakings, the Torlonia family pursued an ambitious policy of acquisition that significantly enriched their collection. A notable example is the celebrated Giustiniani Collection—one of the most distinguished assemblages of ancient sculpture formed in the early seventeenth century by Marchese Vincenzo Giustiniani. In 1816, this group of approximately 260 works was offered as collateral for a loan of 33,600 scudi granted by Giovanni Torlonia to the Giustiniani family.
Following the default on the repayment of the loan, in 1925 the sculptures remained in the custody of the Torlonia family. After a protracted legal dispute, which culminated in 1859, the works were definitively incorporated into the Torlonia Collection, with the formal acquisition occurring between 1857 and 1859. This addition further elevated the status of the collection, endowing it with a core of masterpieces that enhanced its prestige within the European antiquarian landscape.